How Attention Training Helps You Stop Ruminating

Attention Training is a skill that someone with OCD or other anxiety disorders can practice to help them stop rumination and re-engage in more meaningful things.

Rumination is one of the most common compulsions, or safety behaviors, in OCD and anxiety. You are able to ruminate at any time, and therefore at risk of being stuck in your thoughts for hours, days, or weeks. However, a mental technique called “attention training” is a tool often cited by my clients as one of the most useful things they’ve learned in therapy.

Easy Awareness, Effortful Attention

Your mind thinks lots of thoughts. We can divide these thoughts into two categories: (1) Thoughts you can control, and (2) Thoughts you cannot control. Thoughts we can control are our “attention” and thoughts we cannot control are our “awareness.”

The best way to understand these categories is through this simple exercise. Take a moment, if you will, to solve the following math problem, but stop after a few seconds.

What’s 5+5?

Were you able to stop the number “10” from squeezing its way into your consciousness? Almost certainly not. Try as you might, you instantly recognize the answer as “10.” Any efforts to “stop” solving 5+5 are met with further reminders that the answer is in fact 10. This is awareness, the part of thinking that you can’t control, that inserts memories, thoughts, mental images, and this case answers to math questions, into your mind.

What’s 17 times 38?

Image of a meme of a woman intently focusing on a complicated math problem
Giving a thought attention takes a lot of energy and can be exhausting!

Go ahead and stop. If you learned math the way I did, maybe you got as far as 7 times 8, or maybe you were breaking it down into 17 x 30 plus 17 x 8. Unless you’re a mental math whiz, you probably still don’t know the answer. Not knowing the answer is proof that you were able to stop thinking, at least in this way. This is attention; the part of thinking that you can control.

Now, the concept of multiplication or the numbers “17” and “38” might still be hovering around or nagging in your awareness somewhere, but the mental act of multiplying these numbers together is something controllable.

The Art Of Letting Go

Recognizing the difference between attention and awareness, and training your mind to practice acceptance of your awareness while taking agency over your attention, is the goal of “attention training.”

Man holding a small bird in his hands.
Intentionally holding the bird keeps it there, but relaxing and opening your hands gives the bird a chance to leave.

Imagine you’re holding a little songbird in your hand. Your fingers are completely wrapped around his little body. You’re much bigger and stronger than this little bird. So long as you’re holding him he’s going to stay in your hand. Holding the bird in this way is like giving a thought attention. But what if you lay your hand flat, palm up? The bird may still rest in your hand, but now he has the chance to fly away. He may also come back, but as long as you continue to lay your hand open, he will eventually fly away again. Holding the bird, flat palm up, is like accepting, or being willing to be aware of a thought while not giving it attention.

Notice how you don’t have to grab onto another item in order to let go of the bird. You also didn’t have to distract your mind with a new math problem in order to stop solving 17 x 38. We can stop giving our attention to something without having to first give attention to something else.

The distinction between the categories of attention and awareness in the mind can be a fuzzy line, but thankfully we don’t have to spend time worrying about it. Try thinking of it in this user-friendly way: if it FEELS like you just can’t help but continue thinking about something, then those thoughts are “awareness” thoughts by definition. If you aren’t trying to think about something, but are, then this is awareness thinking. When in doubt, chuck the thought process into the “awareness” bucket and practice acceptance rather than control.

Taking Attention Training Another Step With Shifting

Let’s practice again, but with something far grosser than math and birds. Imagine someone had explosive diarrhea right where you’re sitting. Let’s really think about that for a second. You’ve probably been unaware of your butt and chair up until now, but suddenly I’ve forced you to think about exactly where and how you’re sitting. Now stop. Don’t think about it

You can’t. Thoughts related to sitting are likely floating or hovering in your mind. You’re aware of the pressure on your back/bottom/legs/thighs. You’re aware of diarrhea and how it’s very gross. This is awareness. Because awareness is uncontrollable, we’re going to officially give ourselves permission to be aware and allow these thoughts to continue floating or hovering in our mind for as long as they will.

But what if it wasn’t diarrhea. Make a list in your mind of all the other gross things that could’ve happened where you’re sitting. Someone could’ve vomited there, or flicked a booger off, or spilled moldy food on it, or… okay let’s stop. Notice how you’re able to stop explicitly coming up with more examples. That’s attention.

Woman sitting at a desk with stacks of books looking stressed and mentally exhausted. Attention Training would help her disengage from stressful thoughts.
Trying to deal with thoughts through effortful rumination can be exhausting and stressful.

The practice of shifting your attention off of one topic and attending to something else is also part of “attention training.”  We practice this shift over and over and over, that’s the “training” part.

This skill of attention training is applicable to any anxious thought or obsession. Let’s say you made a mistake in your past and you can’t stop thinking about how it hurt others. With attention training, you can learn to recognize when you’re thinking about it using the controllable, effortful part of thinking (attention), and when you’re thinking about it with the uncontrollable, effortless part of thinking (awareness). This leads to being able to more effectively manage mental compulsions or rumination. Maybe you can’t stop hearing your own breath? Practice attention training, and you can develop skills to get back to enjoying music, movies, sports, and life again.

You may have found it hard to stop thinking about other gross things in the diarrhea chair example earlier. This is likely because that specific topic may inspire significantly uncomfortable feelings and emotions in you, making it an example of practicing attention training on what I call “hard mode.” You may have found it easy to stop thinking about other gross things, but you can probably name other topics that would be your personal version of “hard mode” instead. I find the math problem example earlier is attention training on “easy mode” for most. Therefore, it’s the most common method I recommend clients repeat to remind themselves of how attention and awareness feels.

Troubleshooting And Commonly Asked Questions:

Q: Isn’t this just thought suppression?
A: Great question. The simplest answer is thought suppression is when we’re trying to control our awareness. Attention training is about controlling our attention and accepting our awareness for what it is.

Q: If I can’t control my thinking, am I a bad human?
A: If you can’t control your thinking, it means you are human. You may be a human who struggles with accepting they’re a human. You may be a human who struggles with having intensely uncomfortable feelings when thinking certain thoughts. The fact remains that all humans will have thoughts they cannot control, and judging ourselves for it is rarely helpful.

Q: How do I know if my thoughts are attention or awareness? What if I think a bad thought was “awareness” but it was actually “attention,” and therefore I could control it and I’m thinking bad thoughts on purpose?
A: This is an unimportant distinction. If you’re asking this question, immediately dump it into “awareness” and shift your attention away from this unhelpful “side quest” and towards your values and your present moment.

Q: I’m trying to attention train but the thoughts in my awareness are SO LOUD. How do I stop getting distracted by what’s in my awareness?
A: I sometimes want to call attention training “awareness acceptance” instead. By definition, we cannot control if we’re distracted by our awareness. Instead, practice letting go of fighting, analyzing, and judging the thoughts in your awareness, and shift your attention to the present moment (laundry, driving, sending emails, eating lunch, playing guitar, etc.). Then do it again. Then do it again. This is a practice, and we’re going to suck at it initially, and that’s why we’re “training.” 

Q: What if it’s not a thought but a feeling that’s in my awareness?
A: Because thoughts often influence feelings, we can discover some of the power we have to change our feelings by changing our thoughts through attention training. However, my preferred skill for managing feelings is self-compassion as opposed to attention training. Kristin Neff is my go-to for self-compassion resources. You can find more at her website self-compassion.org. 

Written by Anna Chen, AMFT

To learn more about Attention Training and other mindfulness based treatment, like Acceptance And Commitment Therapy, for Obsessive Compulsive Disorder and other anxiety related disorders, please contact The California OCD and Anxiety Treatment Center. We offer online, in-person, group, and IOP treatment in our office in Fullerton, California.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *